Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nick Garner's avatar

Respectable performance marred by few individual errors. This is the first time I think I’d really criticize Gale’s approach to the game. He didn’t start the right players. Sinc should have stayed home. She’s got no business in Orlando heat and humidity, especially if we need to be quick in transition. Our lack of pace at both ends of the pitch left us exposed at the back and Beckie isolated up top. Our passing was a bit off too, even Coffey. May have had something to do with trying to conserve energy and not move off the ball too much.

We’re lucky Hogan didn’t see red. Banda would have been within her rights to be tripped. Hogan has improved but I am curious about Alvarado. I’m really happy for Izzy, especially because I didn’t think she had it in her.

Linnehan has made a case to start over Beckie IMHO, though her being better defensively makes some sense as a sub if we assume we are going to try to hold a lead. Beckie needs to work on her composure and decision-making in the box, though she was often double or triple-teamed without outlets.

I don’t know what Fleming is supposed to be doing. Apparently she completed some passes but I don’t know if they were progressive or chance-creating. I rarely or barely notice when she’s playing. That’s gotta get fixed. So far it seems more like a favor to team Canada to sign her than about building a balanced Thorns roster. She’s got Hina, Moultrie, and sometimes Sinc at least competing for what seems to be her role. Hina and Moultrie as kind of pivoting 8/10s seems the best choice most of the time but Liv has some off games. Sinc gets mostly charity minutes, which is unfortunate and unprofessional IMHO.

Obaze and Payne might have been better choices than Hubly and Reyes for this one. Hubly and Reyes have both been returning to form/improving and maybe Obaze and Payne are still settling in and finding chemistry, but I think they are faster and I haven’t noticed the same mental lapses.

Gale has been doing well so far but LeBlanc and Norris set him up with an unbalanced roster. Some of that is due to us sticking with some older players for consistency during this transition period and to allow them to have honorable send-offs in front of the supporters. Offseason should help if they can make better decisions and not just use Thorns as the Canadian national team’s farm team. I kind of like being honorary Canadian and appreciate the value of cohesion and chemistry, but the club comes before country.

Would have preferred Linnehan and Beckie on the wings, Liv and Hina pivoting in midfield above Coffey, and probably Dias up top. Was valuable to have quality, pace, energy, and creativity off the bench though.

Onward.

Expand full comment
ag167's avatar

Perhaps a different game without Soph -- and you have to remember that the Thorns are already missing Weaver -- but we already know Sinclair and Moultrie in two of the front 3 positions doesn't work!

First half against Seattle: .17 xG, 1 goal

First half against Orlando: .22 xG, 0 goals

There's not enough dynamism, there's not enough speed, and the team isn't tactically set up well enough to go away from home and have 60, 65% possession (which is the only way that kind of front 3 can work).

The Thorns strength under Gale has been counter-pressing and then quick counter-attacks. Can't do that with the lineup they had last night.

The encouraging thing is he quickly made adjustments, but Gale's been wedded to using Sinclair a bit too much IMV when it doesn't match what the Thorns are good at under his coaching. Interested to see how they respond next time.

Expand full comment
238 more comments...

No posts